November 4, 2025

Trump is a hrēowian hurling hysteric. Let's not normalize pathological behavior. Confident in his power, he's unleashed his true self. Bonus: A picture of Dorian Trump

 

During his first term Trump was no less a despicable person desirous of destroying his enemies. He not only had people around him thwarting his sadistic ideas but he knew he had to get elected again. Now, he not only has been re-elected, but he thinks it’s possible he’ll be able to remain as a president who soon to cement his dictatorial power for as long as he wants to.

He rants and rave and this is called by critics unhinged behavior. This is generally just reported on without a diagnostic assessment. This is the psychological equivalent of someone throwing up blood. If a politician did this in public the media would go crazy speculating on what dread disease they had. 

Subscribe for free to receive new posts by email.

Above is a Trump Truth Social Post from yesterday. Most people just shrug off such exercises in verbal explosive diarrhea coming from Trump. They are actually clincial manifestations of multiple psychiatric disorders. That, however, is not where I am going with today’s Substack. I’ve been there and done that since 2017, and I will no doubt do it again. If you are interested my psychological analysis click: 1

It occurred to me that these Truth Social rants have become incredibly boring in addition to being diagnostic.

Why do they even end up like this one. It was covered in articles like this:

At least if he posted “IT WILL NOT BE SUSTAINABLE, AND YOU WILL HRÄ’OWIAN THE DAY THAT YOU VOTED TO DESTROY YOUR LIFE! FAILING TO VOTE TOMORROW IS THE SAME AS VOTING FOR A DEMOCRAT,” people might look the word up and discover that it is an Old English and Germanic word from which the modern word “rue” was derived.

Then someone could have speculated that Trump had taken up reading Old English literature from the 12th Century, perhaps Historia Regum Britanniae.

This would throw Trump’s critics for a loop. If Trump was really as smart and crafty as he wants people to think he is he’d do things like this.

But no, he has a feral go for the jugular intelligence. His insult are one step more sophisticated than “your mother wears combat boots.” (This, by the way, originated in the late 1940s as a mild insult, possibly alluding to poverty or unfashionable choices. It became popular among teenagers and has evolved into a common form of “yo mama” joke. (AI search)

What passes for expressing wit and in his mangled mess of a mind is using the phrase “rue the day” as if he invented it himself. He wants people to marvel at him like he’s an Oscar Wilde level wordsmith and not merely threatening people with schoolyard taunts. It’s doubtful, though, that Trump even knows who Oscar Wilde was and what one of his most famous stories is, although if he did I bet he’d wish he had a portrait of himself in his attic where his image aged and got ugly, while he stayed young.

Thanks for reading Hal Brown's Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

If you appreciate what I post please consider sending a link to friends.

This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

Leave a comment

Previous Substacks

Share Hal Brown's Substack

My comments in RawStory

RawStory: go-to site for breaking news.

Trump psychology

Below are today’s Portland articles about issues related to ICE and similar stories. 

The primary story yesterday was about the federal judge halting National Guard deployment until Nov. 7th. For other stories look at the end of yesterday’s Substack.

Portland media:

KOIN

KGW

OPB

KATU (Sinclair)

Don’t forget, if you missed a recent Substack they are here.

1

AI Overview of my psychological analysis of Donald Trump from Google.

The phrase “Trump mentally ill psychopathic malignant narcissist Hal Brown MSW” refers to the opinions and analysis of

Hal Brown, an MSW (Master of Social Work) and retired psychotherapist, who has written extensively on the subject of Donald Trump’s mental state.

Hal Brown, along with other mental health professionals, has publicly expressed the view that Donald Trump exhibits signs of serious mental health issues, specifically characterizing him as a “psychopathic sadistic malignant narcissist” who is “dangerously mentally ill” and “unfit for office”. His views are often shared in blog posts on platforms like Daily Kos and Substack.

Key points regarding these claims:

  • Professional Opinion: Brown is a mental health professional (retired) who writes from his perspective as a clinician.

  • Public Stance: He is associated with the “Duty to Warn” movement, a group of mental health professionals who have argued that mental health experts have a professional and ethical responsibility to alert the public to the dangers they perceive in Trump’s behavior.

  • Ethical Considerations: Mainstream psychiatric and psychological associations generally adhere to the Goldwater Rule, an ethical guideline stating that it is irresponsible for mental health professionals to give a professional opinion about public figures they have not personally examined and for whom they have not obtained consent to discuss their mental health. Brown and others in the “Duty to Warn” group argue that this rule should not prevent professionals from speaking out when they perceive a danger to the public.

  • Formal Diagnosis: As Brown has not personally examined Donald Trump, his assessments are not formal clinical diagnoses in a medical sense but rather professional opinions based on Trump’s public behavior and statements.

More:

Hal Brown, MSW (Master of Social Work), a retired psychotherapist, who has written numerous online articles and blog posts arguing that Donald Trump is a “mentally ill, psychopathic, sadistic, malignant narcissist”.

Hal Brown is known for his contributions to the discussion regarding Donald Trump’s mental health, particularly within the context of the “Duty to Warn” movement. This movement involved mental health professionals who believed they had an ethical obligation to inform the public about what they perceived as Donald Trump’s psychological instability and potential danger, despite the traditional “Goldwater Rule” (which advises against diagnosing public figures without a personal examination and consent).

Brown’s arguments are presented in his writings on platforms like Substack and Medium, where he analyzes Trump’s behavior and statements through the lens of mental health concepts, such as malignant narcissism and psychopathy. His assessment is an individual professional opinion and part of a broader, ongoing public debate among mental health professionals about the ethics and validity of diagnosing a public figure from afar.

Hal M. Brown, MSW's psychological analysis of Donald Trump from Google AI, and more.

 

AI Overview of my psychological analysis of Donald Trump from Google.

The phrase “Trump mentally ill psychopathic malignant narcissist Hal Brown MSW” refers to the opinions and analysis of

Hal Brown, an MSW (Master of Social Work) and retired psychotherapist, who has written extensively on the subject of Donald Trump’s mental state.

Hal Brown, along with other mental health professionals, has publicly expressed the view that Donald Trump exhibits signs of serious mental health issues, specifically characterizing him as a “psychopathic sadistic malignant narcissist” who is “dangerously mentally ill” and “unfit for office”. His views are often shared in blog posts on platforms like Daily Kos and Substack.

Key points regarding these claims:

  • Professional Opinion: Brown is a mental health professional (retired) who writes from his perspective as a clinician.
  • Public Stance: He is associated with the “Duty to Warn” movement, a group of mental health professionals who have argued that mental health experts have a professional and ethical responsibility to alert the public to the dangers they perceive in Trump’s behavior.
  • Ethical Considerations: Mainstream psychiatric and psychological associations generally adhere to the Goldwater Rule, an ethical guideline stating that it is irresponsible for mental health professionals to give a professional opinion about public figures they have not personally examined and for whom they have not obtained consent to discuss their mental health. Brown and others in the “Duty to Warn” group argue that this rule should not prevent professionals from speaking out when they perceive a danger to the public.
  • Formal Diagnosis: As Brown has not personally examined Donald Trump, his assessments are not formal clinical diagnoses in a medical sense but rather professional opinions based on Trump’s public behavior and statements.

More:

Hal Brown, MSW (Master of Social Work), a retired psychotherapist, who has written numerous online articles and blog posts arguing that Donald Trump is a “mentally ill, psychopathic, sadistic, malignant narcissist”.

Hal Brown is known for his contributions to the discussion regarding Donald Trump’s mental health, particularly within the context of the “Duty to Warn” movement. This movement involved mental health professionals who believed they had an ethical obligation to inform the public about what they perceived as Donald Trump’s psychological instability and potential danger, despite the traditional “Goldwater Rule” (which advises against diagnosing public figures without a personal examination and consent).

Brown’s arguments are presented in his writings on platforms like Substack and Medium, where he analyzes Trump’s behavior and statements through the lens of mental health concepts, such as malignant narcissism and psychopathy. His assessment is an individual professional opinion and part of a broader, ongoing public debate among mental health professionals about the ethics and validity of diagnosing a public figure from afar.1

AI Overview of my psychological analysis of Donald Trump from Google.

The phrase “Trump mentally ill psychopathic malignant narcissist Hal Brown MSW” refers to the opinions and analysis of

Hal Brown, an MSW (Master of Social Work) and retired psychotherapist, who has written extensively on the subject of Donald Trump’s mental state.

Hal Brown, along with other mental health professionals, has publicly expressed the view that Donald Trump exhibits signs of serious mental health issues, specifically characterizing him as a “psychopathic sadistic malignant narcissist” who is “dangerously mentally ill” and “unfit for office”. His views are often shared in blog posts on platforms like Daily Kos and Substack.

Key points regarding these claims:

  • Professional Opinion: Brown is a mental health professional (retired) who writes from his perspective as a clinician.
  • Public Stance: He is associated with the “Duty to Warn” movement, a group of mental health professionals who have argued that mental health experts have a professional and ethical responsibility to alert the public to the dangers they perceive in Trump’s behavior.
  • Ethical Considerations: Mainstream psychiatric and psychological associations generally adhere to the Goldwater Rule, an ethical guideline stating that it is irresponsible for mental health professionals to give a professional opinion about public figures they have not personally examined and for whom they have not obtained consent to discuss their mental health. Brown and others in the “Duty to Warn” group argue that this rule should not prevent professionals from speaking out when they perceive a danger to the public.
  • Formal Diagnosis: As Brown has not personally examined Donald Trump, his assessments are not formal clinical diagnoses in a medical sense but rather professional opinions based on Trump’s public behavior and statements.

More:

Hal Brown, MSW (Master of Social Work), a retired psychotherapist, who has written numerous online articles and blog posts arguing that Donald Trump is a “mentally ill, psychopathic, sadistic, malignant narcissist”.

Hal Brown is known for his contributions to the discussion regarding Donald Trump’s mental health, particularly within the context of the “Duty to Warn” movement. This movement involved mental health professionals who believed they had an ethical obligation to inform the public about what they perceived as Donald Trump’s psychological instability and potential danger, despite the traditional “Goldwater Rule” (which advises against diagnosing public figures without a personal examination and consent).

Brown’s arguments are presented in his writings on platforms like Substack and Medium, where he analyzes Trump’s behavior and statements through the lens of mental health concepts, such as malignant narcissism and psychopathy. His assessment is an individual professional opinion and part of a broader, ongoing public debate among mental health professionals about the ethics and validity of diagnosing a public figure from afar.

The following in not from AI:

I began writing about what I considered to be Trump's dangerous psychopatholgy in 2016 in Daily Kos here. Note the comments on this post.

This is one of the noteworthy comments to my Kos article:

I’m not a medical or psychiatric professional.  I simply lived 18 years under the same roof and at the mercy of two parents who showed me what sociopaths and malignant narcissists look like when they’re just being themselves, with no one watching who might be important enough or professionally trained enough in the field of behavioral disorders to actually apply those diagnoses with some authority.  

Starting in the 1980’s and beyond, we’ve had access to many pieces of literature and appearances by experts on venues such as Oprah, specifically intended to help the lay person (with the emphasis on women) recognize someone who was dangerous to their life.  

There wasn’t a lot of emphasis on terminology in most of those offerings, although the names of the personality disorders that can inflict such damage on others were certainly mentioned and characteristics for each were given.  It was only then, after decades of trying to figure out what had happened to me and my siblings and how it had impacted us as adults (starting with PTSD, major depression, and panic disorder) that I actually learned the terminology for behaviors I had witnessed all my life.  

The irony is that when someone with a personality disorder can be tricked or forced into sitting in front of a mental professional, they usually never behave in the way they do in private, when they’re “just being themselves” in the company of those they are victimizing.   When they need to, they usually have the ability to be “charming” or at least “very nice.”  

As individuals, in our private lives, we have to decide whether we want to allow a particular person into our life, or to remain in our life, based on what they’ve been willing to show us and tell us about who they are.  We want to know if we will be safe in a relationship with them, whatever that relationship might be.  

As a nation, we are now faced with the decision as to whether someone that most of us would never allow to be a part of our personal, private life in any capacity, is someone we want to vote for to do the hardest job in the world.  Whether or not you decide to attach a label to him, he is showing us exactly who and what he is.  Extraordinarily dangerous.  

I summarized what I wrote in Daily Kos and more in a column I wrote for Capitol Hill Bue.

While I was one of the first clnicians to join Dr. John D. Gartner's Duty to Warn Group in 2017. I never rose to the level of national prominence he, Dr. Mary Trump, Dr. Bandy Lee (who edited the best seller "The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump") and several other clincians did. My only national media exposure was in Salon where their columnist Chaucey DeVega quoted me in several aritcles and had me on his podcast. Here's an example:

For those who came across this who want to read my most recent opinions about Trump and politics check out my free substack. I rarely miss a daily post. As of Nov. 4th this is what it looks like:

November 3, 2025

CBS News and 60 Minutes have been flushed down the Trump toilet. By Hal M. Brown

 



This story made HuffPost’s top of the page:

It was also a main story in Salon:

RawStory covered some of the social media reaction:

Popular Substacker Robert Hubel wrote about it:

If Trump hadn’t been his usual self and done at least a modified limited mea culpa on the question about his pardon for the cryptocurrency crook he might have skated on this.

All these stories made the news, it appears because someone at Daily Beast read the transcript. Oddly, nobody at 60 Minutes thought to censor the transcript which they put on their website.

This gave ammunition to Chuck Schumer. Here’s his tweet:

This was picked up by various media, for example:

This is from Who, What, Why:

I like this line:

There is plenty more we could say about the interview. Some of it is disturbing, and some is amusing, for example, that Trump still doesn’t seem to understand the difference between asylum seekers and mental patients in insane asylums.

I skimmed the 60 Minutes transcript (as of this writing it is still here). 

Trump speachified endlessly in response to all of O’Donnell’s questions. He batted off her attempts to pin him down on his lies, deceptions, and the just plain authoritarian, nasty, and evil things he’d been doing.

Consider just this one exchange:

NORAH O’DONNELL: --and you succeeded on that. Illegal crossings at the Southern border are at a 55-year low. Want to ask you about this. More recently, Americans have been watching videos of ICE tackling a young mother, tear gas being used in a Chicago residential neighborhood, and the smashing of car windows. Have some of these raids gone too far?

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: No. I think they haven’t gone far enough because we’ve been held back by the-- by the judges, by the liberal judges that were put in by Biden and by Obama. We’ve been held--

NORAH O’DONNELL: You’re okay with those tactics?

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Yeah, because you have to get the people out. You know, you have to look at the people. Many of them are murderers. Many of them are people that were thrown outta their countries because they were, you know, criminals. Many of them are people from jails and prisons. Many of them are people from frankly mental institutions. I feel badly about that, but they’re released from insane asylums. You know why? Because they’re killers.

NORAH O’DONNELL: Well, you promised in your campaign that you were going to deport the worst of the worst, violent criminals--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: That’s what I’m-- oh we’re doin’ that--

NORAH O’DONNELL: --rapists.

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Well, that’s what we’re doing--

NORAH O’DONNELL: But a lot of the people that your administration has arrested and deported aren’t violent criminals. Landscapers, nannies, construction workers--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Oh, no, no, landscapers who are criminals--

NORAH O’DONNELL: --farmworkers.

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Now, look, look.

NORAH O’DONNELL: The family of US service members--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: I need landscapers and I need farmers more than anybody, okay.

NORAH O’DONNELL: But was it your in--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: We-- and we want to-- we focus on the bad ones, and we’ve gotten tremendous numbers of bad people. Don’t forget.

NORAH O’DONNELL: The-- there--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: When you have over 11,000 murderers released into our country, over 11,000, 50% of which have murdered more than one person, we gotta get ‘em outta here.

NORAH O’DONNELL: Is it your intent to deport people who do not have a criminal record?

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: We have to start off with a policy, and the policy has to be you came into the country illegally, you’re gonna go out. However, you’ve also seen, you’re gonna go out. We’re gonna work with you, and you’re gonna come back into our country legally. Because we have a lotta good people. We have some great people. But, you know, the problem we have, and people don’t like talking about-- these are very--

NORAH O’DONNELL: But there isn’t--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: --wait. These are very smart countries. Their leaders are very smart. They’re very street-wise. They might not have gone to the finest schools, but they’re very street-wise. They want-- they don’t want, they have good people. They want people that are bad out.

So they, what do they do? They open their jails. They let ‘em out. They get rid of their drug dealers. They let ‘em out. But you know who else they get out? The people that are on welfare that aren’t working. In other words, they have people that just don’t work. They don’t want people that just don’t work, so they put them into our country.

NORAH O’DONNELL: But if someone has been in this--

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: And we’ve accepted all of these people because of Biden’s open border policy where people would walk in totally unchecked and unvetted, murderers and everybody else.

NORAH O’DONNELL: When will you declare mission accomplished on immigration?

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Well, it takes a long time, because, you know, probably I say 25 million people were let into our country. A lotta people say it was 10 million people. But whether it was ten or-- I believe I’m much closer to the right number. Of the 25, many of them should not be here. Many of them.

But we’re-- we’re cleaning up our cities. You know, I campaigned on crime, but I’ve done a much better job on crime than I thought. You know, the crime numbers are way down, even though we have a lot more people in our country that really shouldn’t be here. And many of them are stone-cold hard criminals. When I look at D.C. now, you can walk down the middle of the street. You can have your daughter who’s ten years old meet you at the park. She’s gonna be okay.

Just on the brutality of some of the ICE enforcement, she should have shown videos of some of the worst examples and demanded Trump justify what his agents did.

In his justifications she could have said “it sounds like you’re expressing the belief of Niccolò Machiavelli and saying that the end always justifies the means no matter what the means are.” This might have thrown him off since I doubt he knows who Machiavelli was, or what the phrase means:

The end justifies the means is a paraphrase of Niccolò Machiavelli. It means that if a goal is morally important enough, any method of getting it is acceptable. The idea is very old, but it was not meant to allow people to be cruel or mean if they do not need to be. It was part of a political philosophy (way of thinking) called consequentialism. The basic idea is that doing something can be judged by what happens because of it. All modern forms of consequentialism have to prevent tyrants(absolute rulers) from using this idea for evil. (Wikipedia)

She could also have said something to the effect of “what would you say to a devout Christian who told you that your immigration enforcement would be something Jesus would be preaching against?” She could have quoted the Bible to him. 

She also could have tried to pin him down with a similar line of questioning about blowing up boats and executing low level people he says are drug smugglers who are only poor fisherman trying to make money to feed their families.

I suppose she felt she HAD to do the interview. She was incredibly niave or shamelessly overconfident if she thought she could best Trump. 

I can’t see how she could have handled it better unless she was willing to get up and walk out saying he was a fucking liar, a cruel man, and someone hellbent on being a dictator. Of course she’d have lost her job and Trump would probably have put a hit on her, but at least she’d have come away with some self-respect.

Basically, Trump with this one glitch aside, won another battle in his effort to control the media.

Addendum: Fox News had only complements about the 60 Minutes interview and thought enough of this part to put it in their headline:

Trump taunts ‘60 Minutes’ during interview, says show paid him ‘a lot of money’

Paramount and CBS settled election interference lawsuit with Trump this year

………..

Thanks for reading my Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Leave a comment

Previous Substacks

Share Hal Brown's Substack

My comments in RawStory

RawStory: go-to site for breaking news.

Below are the most recent Portland articles about issues related to ICE and similar stories. For other stories look at the end of yesterday’s Substack.

Portland media:

KOIN

KGW

OPB

KATU (Sinclair)

Don’t forget, if you missed a recent Substack they are here.

Trump is a hrēowian hurling hysteric. Let's not normalize pathological behavior. Confident in his power, he's unleashed his true self. Bonus: A picture of Dorian Trump

  During his first term Trump was no less a despicable person desirous of destroying his enemies. He not only had people around him thwartin...